Answer six questions before you read on
1You pay someone A$40 an hour. What does an hour of their productive work cost you?
Often A$55–65. Super, leave, public holidays, payroll tax, workers compensation and non-productive time all add to it, and productive hours are far fewer than paid hours.
2How many weeks a year is a full-time employee actually available to work?
Around 46–47, after annual leave, public holidays and typical personal leave. Then a share of those hours goes on admin, travel, training and waiting.
3If you charge their time out at twice their wage, are you making money?
Not necessarily. Twice the wage may barely cover the fully loaded cost per productive hour plus overheads.
4A new hire starts on Monday. When will they be fully productive?
Often three to six months, sometimes longer. You pay the full cost from day one, and your own time on training is a cost too.
5Is a contractor cheaper than an employee?
Sometimes per hour, often not per year. And if someone is a contractor in name but works like an employee, you may owe super, leave and penalties.
6What extra sales do you need to pay for the hire?
Their full cost divided by your gross margin. At a 40% margin, a A$100,000 total cost needs A$250,000 of extra sales a year, unless the hire raises margin or frees you for higher-value work.
What's in the full cost
| Cost | What it is | Where the rate comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Base pay | Salary or hourly wage, at least the award or agreement minimum | The relevant award, agreement or contract |
| Super | Super Guarantee on ordinary time earnings | The current Super Guarantee rate |
| Payroll tax | State tax on wages above a threshold | Your state or territory revenue office |
| Workers compensation | Compulsory insurance premium | Your state scheme and industry rate |
| Leave | Annual leave, personal leave, public holidays, long service leave; leave loading where the award provides | National Employment Standards, award and state law |
| Penalty rates and overtime | Weekend, evening, public holiday and overtime rates | The award or agreement |
| Other costs | Equipment, vehicle, phone, software licences, uniforms, training, recruitment | Your own costs |
The usual advice, and what it misses
- "Add about 20–30% on-costs to the salary." Ignores productive hours, which is where most of the gap is.
- "Charge out at two or three times the wage." A rough rule, not a calculation.
- "Hire when you're too busy." Busy isn't the same as profitable, and ramp-up costs come first.
Calculate the full cost per productive hour
Enter your own current rates. Super, payroll tax and workers compensation rates change, and payroll tax and workers compensation vary by state and industry.
Price their time from the real cost
A A$60 productive-hour cost at a 55% target margin gives a charge-out rate of about A$133. Use your required margin (see real margin per job).
Can you afford the hire?
- Extra sales needed = full yearly cost ÷ your gross margin %.
- Is the work there? Check your pipeline or the demand you're turning away.
- Allow for ramp-up. Assume reduced productivity for the first three to six months.
- Check cash. Add the cost to your 13-week forecast, including super and payroll tax timing.
- Consider what it frees. If the hire frees the owner for higher-value work, count that too, but only if you'll actually do it.
Employee, casual or contractor?
| Option | Cost pattern | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Permanent full-time or part-time | Base pay plus leave, super and on-costs | Fixed cost; ramp-up; leave liability |
| Casual | Higher hourly rate with a casual loading instead of paid leave, plus super | Award conditions; casual conversion rules; reliability of hours |
| Contractor | An agreed rate; no leave | Must genuinely be a contractor. If they work like an employee, super and other obligations can still apply |
| Labour hire | Agency rate including their costs and margin | Higher hourly cost; flexible |
Classifying workers wrongly is costly. The ATO and Fair Work Ombudsman both provide tools to check whether someone is an employee or a contractor.
The real cost of a hire in six businesses
These are composite businesses with illustrative figures, built to show how the method works. They are not CFOSurge client results.
Electrician hiring a first employee
Full cost (illustrative example rates)
| Base pay | A$70,000 |
| Super, workers compensation, tools, vehicle share, phone | A$18,000 |
| Total yearly cost | A$88,000 |
| Productive hours after leave, holidays, travel and admin | about 1,400 |
| Cost per productive hour | about A$63 |
| Charge-out rate at a 50% target margin | about A$126 an hour |
The diagnosis
The electrician had planned to charge the new hire out at A$85 an hour, which would have covered cost but left almost nothing for overheads and profit.
The electrician also hadn't allowed for their own time. Supervising and training a new tradesperson took about five hours a week for the first three months, which is time not billed.
The full solution, in order
- Charge the hire's time from the productive-hour cost.
- Have enough work booked before they start.
- Budget ramp-up at reduced productivity for three months.
- Register for PAYG withholding and set up payroll and super before the first pay run.
- Budget your own supervision time as a cost of the hire for the first three months.
- Check the award for the tradesperson's classification, allowances and overtime rules.
- Arrange workers compensation insurance before they start.
Don't do this
- Pricing from the wage.
- Hiring a contractor who works like an employee.
- Ignoring the owner's time spent training.
Numbers to watch every month
- Billable hours of the employee
- Margin on their work
- Owner billable hours during ramp-up
Builder hiring a site supervisor
Full cost (illustrative example rates)
| Base pay | A$120,000 |
| Super, payroll tax, workers compensation, vehicle | A$30,000 |
| Total yearly cost | A$150,000 |
| Extra work needed at a 15% gross margin | A$1.0M a year |
| Decision | Hire only with the work in hand, or if margin fade can be cut |
The diagnosis
A supervisor is a fixed overhead, not a billable resource. The case for hiring rests on running more jobs or reducing margin fade and rework.
The decision turned on a number nobody had measured: margin fade. Once the builder saw that fade averaged five points, a supervisor who cut it by even two points on A$2.4M of work would cover most of their cost.
The full solution, in order
- Quantify current margin fade; if supervision can cut it by two points on A$2.4M, that's A$48,000.
- Check work in hand covers the extra volume.
- Include payroll tax if total wages pass the threshold.
- Measure margin fade on the last ten jobs before deciding.
- Write the role around outcomes: fade, rework, programme time.
- Review after six months against those outcomes.
Don't do this
- Hiring on a busy month.
- Treating a supervisor as billable.
Numbers to watch every month
- Margin fade
- Work in hand
- Overhead as a share of sales
- Rework hours
- Jobs finished on programme
Online store hiring a warehouse assistant
Comparison (illustrative example)
| Part-time, 25 hours a week, with leave | about A$44,000 a year all-in |
| Casual, same hours, with casual loading | about A$45,500 a year all-in |
| Hours needed | Peak season 35, quiet season 15 |
| Decision | Casual, rostered to the forecast |
The diagnosis
The yearly cost was similar. Seasonal demand made casual hours the better fit, as long as rostering follows the forecast.
The real lever was rostering to the forecast. A casual rostered for 35 hours in peak and 15 in the quiet season cost far less than a part-timer on 25 hours all year, without losing capacity when it mattered.
The full solution, in order
- Roster to forecast orders, not habit.
- Check the award for minimum engagement and casual conversion rules.
- Measure orders packed per hour.
- Forecast orders by week and roster from it two weeks ahead.
- Set a target for orders packed per labour hour.
- Review the casual's pattern regularly against the award's casual conversion rules.
Don't do this
- Paying for peak hours all year.
- Ignoring award minimums.
- Paying for peak staffing all year.
Numbers to watch every month
- Orders per labour hour
- Wages as a share of sales
- Wages as a share of sales by month
Consultancy hiring a senior consultant
Full cost (illustrative example rates)
| Base pay | A$110,000 |
| Super, payroll tax, workers compensation, laptop, software, training | A$25,000 |
| Total yearly cost | A$135,000 |
| Billable hours at 70% utilisation | about 1,250 |
| Cost per billable hour | about A$108 |
| Charge-out rate at a 55% target margin | about A$240 an hour |
The diagnosis
The firm's standard rate for that level was A$190, below what the role needed. Either the rate had to rise or utilisation had to be higher.
The gap between the A$190 standard rate and the A$240 the role needed also showed a broader issue: the firm's rates had been set by looking at competitors, not at its own cost per billable hour.
The full solution, in order
- Set rates from cost per billable hour and target margin.
- Plan utilisation realistically; 70% is good for a consultant.
- Budget for ramp-up.
- Recalculate rates for every level from cost per billable hour and target margin.
- Plan the hire's utilisation month by month for the first year.
- Use the hire to free senior time for higher-rate work, and track that it happens.
Don't do this
- Rates set by competitors alone.
- Assuming full utilisation from month one.
Numbers to watch every month
- Utilisation
- Realisation
- Margin per consultant
- Senior staff hours on advisory work
- Rate realised per level
Café hiring a full-time cook
Full cost (illustrative example)
| Base pay at award rate | about A$62,000 |
| Weekend and evening penalty rates | about A$9,000 |
| Super and workers compensation | about A$9,000 |
| Total yearly cost | about A$80,000 |
| Effect | Wages rise about 3 points as a share of sales |
The diagnosis
Penalty rates are a large part of hospitality labour cost and must be in the plan. The hire made sense only if the kitchen could serve more covers or cut the owner's hours.
Penalty rates make the roster itself a pricing decision. The same 38 hours cost noticeably more if they fall on weekends and evenings, so the cook's shifts were planned around the trading pattern, not habit.
The full solution, in order
- Cost the roster with the award's penalty rates.
- Set a covers target that pays for the role.
- Track wages % weekly.
- Cost the roster with penalty rates before confirming the hire.
- Use the Fair Work pay tool to check rates for the classification.
- Set a covers-per-cook-hour target and review it weekly.
Don't do this
- Costing at base rate.
- Underpaying penalty rates.
- Rostering full-time staff into quiet periods.
Numbers to watch every month
- Wages % of sales
- Covers per labour hour
- Wages on weekends and evenings as a share of takings
Manufacturer hiring a machine operator
Comparison (illustrative example)
| New operator, full cost | about A$90,000 a year |
| Overtime for the same extra output | about A$65,000 a year |
| Volume at which a hire is cheaper | about 40% more extra hours |
| Decision | Overtime now; hire when the order book reaches the threshold |
The diagnosis
Overtime costs more per hour, but only for the hours needed. At current volume, it was cheaper in total; a hire made sense once extra hours rose further.
Sustained overtime also has a hidden cost: fatigue raises error and injury risk. The plan set a limit on overtime hours per person, beyond which hiring would be triggered regardless of the cost comparison.
The full solution, in order
- Compare total cost, not hourly cost.
- Watch fatigue and safety on sustained overtime.
- Set a trigger in the order book for hiring.
- Set a maximum overtime level per person for safety and quality.
- Track yield and errors during overtime periods.
- Line up recruitment early so a hire can start when the trigger is reached.
Don't do this
- Sustained heavy overtime.
- Hiring ahead of confirmed orders.
Numbers to watch every month
- Overtime hours
- Order book
- Output per labour hour
- Yield during overtime
- Incidents and near misses
Hover over a business for a preview (tap on a phone), then click to open the full case.
Stage 9 · AvoidSeven hiring cost mistakes
7 mistakes
- Costing on paid hours instead of productive hours.
- Forgetting payroll tax when the hire takes you over the threshold.
- Ignoring ramp-up.
- Paying below the award or misreading penalty rates.
- Sham contracting.
- Leaving leave liability off the balance sheet.
- Pricing their time from the wage.
Stage 10 · DecideHire decision guide
Summary table
| Situation | Usually best |
|---|---|
| Steady, ongoing demand | Permanent employee |
| Variable or seasonal demand | Casual or part-time |
| Specialist, project-based work | Genuine contractor |
| Short-term peak | Labour hire or overtime |
| Owner overloaded with admin | Part-time admin or bookkeeper, to free owner time for revenue |
Official sources and guidance
Rules, rates and thresholds change. Check the current position at these official sources before acting.
- ATO: Super for employersCurrent Super Guarantee rate, who you pay super for, and due dates.
- business.gov.au: Payroll taxLinks to each state and territory's payroll tax rules.
- Fair Work Ombudsman: National Employment StandardsMinimum leave, hours and other entitlements.
- Fair Work Ombudsman: Minimum wagesCurrent minimum and award wages.
- Fair Work Ombudsman: Pay and conditions toolAward pay rates, penalty rates and allowances.
- ATO: Employees vs independent contractorsHow the ATO decides whether a worker is an employee.
- Fair Work Ombudsman: Independent contractorsRights and obligations, and sham contracting.
- ATO: Single Touch PayrollPayroll reporting requirements for employers.
- ATO: Hiring a new workerTax and super steps when you take someone on.
ReferenceKey terms in plain English
9 terms
- On-costs
- Costs of employment beyond base pay: super, payroll tax, workers compensation, leave.
- Productive hours
- Paid hours less leave, holidays and non-productive time.
- Super Guarantee
- Compulsory employer superannuation contributions on ordinary time earnings.
- Payroll tax
- A state or territory tax on wages above a threshold.
- Workers compensation
- Compulsory insurance covering workplace injury.
- National Employment Standards
- Minimum employment entitlements in the Fair Work Act, including leave and public holidays.
- Casual loading
- A higher hourly rate paid to casual employees instead of paid leave.
- Utilisation
- Billable hours ÷ available hours.
- Sham contracting
- Treating an employee as a contractor to avoid employer obligations.
Questions owners also ask
What does an employee cost on top of salary?
Super, payroll tax if you're over your state's threshold, workers compensation, equipment and other costs, plus the cost of leave and public holidays. Per productive hour, the full cost is often 1.3–1.6 times the hourly wage.
How do I calculate cost per productive hour?
Add base pay, super, payroll tax, workers compensation and other costs for the year, then divide by productive hours: paid hours less annual leave, public holidays, personal leave and non-productive time.
How much should I charge for an employee's time?
Divide the cost per productive hour by (1 − your target gross margin). At A$60 an hour and a 55% margin, about A$133.
Can I afford to hire?
Divide the full yearly cost by your gross margin to find the extra sales needed, check the work is there, allow for three to six months of ramp-up, and test it in your cash forecast.
Is a contractor cheaper than an employee?
Sometimes, but someone who works like an employee may legally be one, with super and other obligations. Use the ATO and Fair Work tools to check.
Casual or permanent?
Casual suits variable demand; permanent suits steady work. Total cost is often similar once casual loading is included.
When do I have to pay payroll tax?
When your total Australian wages exceed your state or territory's threshold. Check your revenue office for the current threshold and rate.
Related owner questions
Want a second pair of eyes on this?
If you're planning a hire and want the cost and cash impact modelled first, CFOSurge's Australian CFO team can work through it with you, using your actual numbers.