CFOSurge Australia/Owner questions/Margin

What's my real margin on each job or product? And what margin do I actually need?

6 steps to get there, and a 3-minute check to find where you start.

The problem

Your overall margin is an average, and averages hide the work that quietly loses money.

The way out

Cost each job properly, rank your work by margin per scarce resource, and set the margin you actually need.

The way out, step by step

Six readings to find your real margin

Hover over a step to light it up, click to open it.Tap a step to open it. 0 of 6 explored

★Every job earning its keep
Margin unknown: one average hides the losers

Not sure which step you’re on?

Take the 3-minute check. Your result lights up your step above.

The full guide

Everything behind your answer, in detail

Read only the sections you need. Each one stands on its own.

Prepared by the CFOSurge Australia team

The answer in brief

Gross margin is the price you charge, excluding GST, less the direct costs of delivering that job or product: materials, fully loaded labour, subcontractors and other direct costs such as freight, fees and waste. Measure it per job, product or customer, not just in total. Then compare work by margin per unit of your scarcest resource, such as per labour hour, machine hour or table, because that shows which work truly pays. The margin you need is your own: overheads plus owner pay plus target profit, divided by sales. Industry averages are a sense check, not a target.

On this page
  1. Six questions first
  2. Margin, markup, contribution
  3. The usual advice
  4. Cost a job properly
  5. Rank work by your constraint
  6. The margin you need
  7. Six businesses
  8. What to do with the list
  9. Costing mistakes
  10. Decision grid
  11. Official sources
  12. Key terms
  13. Questions owners also ask
Stage 1 · Notice

Answer six questions before you read on

1Which job, product or customer made you the most money last month?

Most owners name the biggest. The biggest by sales is often not the best by margin, and sometimes it loses money once every cost is counted.

2You add 30% to your costs. What's your margin?

About 23%, not 30%. Markup is a percentage of cost; margin is a percentage of price. Mixing them up is one of the most common pricing errors.

3What does one hour of your team's labour really cost?

Far more than the hourly wage. Add super, leave, public holidays, payroll tax, workers compensation and the paid hours that aren't productive, and it's often 1.3–1.6 times the wage per productive hour.

4Do your job costs include your own hours?

If the owner's time is left out, jobs look more profitable than they are, and the business can't afford to replace the owner.

5A job covers all its direct costs. Is it profitable?

Not yet. It has to contribute enough margin to pay its share of overheads and profit. Covering direct costs only stops it losing money directly.

6Your margin matches the industry average. Is it enough?

Only if your overheads match the average too. The margin you need depends on your own overheads, owner pay and profit target.

Stage 2 · Understand

Margin, markup and contribution: three different numbers

MeasureFormulaExample: cost A$70, price A$100
Gross margin(Price − direct cost) ÷ price30%
Markup(Price − direct cost) ÷ direct cost43%
Gross profitPrice − direct costA$30
Margin per hourGross profit ÷ labour hoursA$30 ÷ hours used

All prices exclude GST. Overall gross margin on your profit and loss is the average across everything you sell, which can hide work that loses money.

Stage 3 · Question the usual advice

The usual advice, and why it misleads

  • "Check your gross margin on the P&L." It's an average, and averages hide losers.
  • "Aim for the industry benchmark." Ignores your overheads.
  • "Cost labour at the hourly rate." Understates labour by a third or more.
  • "Focus on high-margin products." A high percentage on low volume or a slow job may earn less than a lower percentage on fast work.
Stage 4 · Rebuild

Cost one job or product properly

Direct costs are every cost that wouldn't exist if you hadn't done this job or sold this product:

  • Materials or stock, including waste, freight in and consumables.
  • Labour at its fully loaded cost per productive hour, including the owner's hours. See the true cost of an employee.
  • Subcontractors.
  • Other direct costs: travel time, delivery, merchant and platform fees, packaging, returns, warranty and rework.
Work out the real margin on a job or productExample figures · replace with yours
Stage 5 · Rank

Rank your work by margin per scarce resource

Percentage margin tells you how much of each sale you keep. It doesn't tell you which work makes the most money, because work uses your capacity at different rates. Every business has one resource that runs out first:

Trades and services

Billable hours. Rank by gross profit per labour hour.

Manufacturing

The bottleneck machine or line. Rank by gross profit per machine hour.

Retail

Cash tied up in stock, or shelf space. Rank by GMROI or gross profit per metre.

Hospitality

Seats and kitchen time. Rank dishes by gross profit per dish and popularity.

Do it in a spreadsheet: one row per job, product or customer for the last three to six months, sorted by margin per constraint. The top and bottom fifth of the list are where the decisions are.

Stage 6 · Set the target

The margin you need, and industry ranges

Required margin
=
Overheads + owner pay + target profitfor the year
÷
Salesexcluding GST

If your actual gross margin is below that, no amount of extra sales fixes it; each sale contributes too little. Rough orientation ranges for gross margin, which vary widely with what's counted as a direct cost:

IndustryTypical gross margin rangeUsually counted as direct cost
Trades and construction15–35%Materials, labour, subcontractors
Retail and e-commerce30–55%Stock, freight, platform fees
Professional services40–70%Fee-earner salaries
Hospitality60–72% on food and beverage before labourFood and beverage cost; add labour for prime cost
Manufacturing25–45%Materials, direct labour, production overheads

The ATO publishes small business benchmarks by industry, based on business tax data. They're a useful second check, and the ATO uses them to spot businesses that look out of line.

Stage 7 · Compare

What job-level margin revealed in six businesses

In every case, the overall margin looked acceptable. The detail didn't.

These are composite businesses with illustrative figures, built to show how the method works. They are not CFOSurge client results.

Hover over a business for a preview (tap on a phone), then click to open the full case.

Stage 8 · Act

What to do with the bottom of the list

  1. Reprice first.

    Most low-margin work is underpriced, not unprofitable by nature.

  2. Redesign the work.

    Change the scope, minimum order, call-out fee, packaging or delivery so it costs less to serve.

  3. Reduce the direct cost.

    Supplier terms, waste, rework and travel time are often the easiest savings.

  4. Move volume up the list.

    Direct sales and marketing effort toward the work at the top.

  5. Stop doing what can't be fixed.

    Losing a low-margin customer often frees capacity for better work. Check first that it doesn't carry overheads you can't cut.

Stage 9 · Avoid

Seven costing mistakes

7 mistakes
  • Confusing markup and margin.
  • Costing labour at the wage rate.
  • Leaving out the owner's hours.
  • Ignoring waste, rework and warranty.
  • Forgetting fees: merchant, platform, finance.
  • Using GST-inclusive prices.
  • Judging work by percentage alone rather than margin per scarce resource.
Stage 10 · Decide

Decision grid

Summary table
Margin per constraintVolumeAction
HighHighProtect and grow
HighLowMarket it harder
LowHighReprice or redesign: biggest opportunity
LowLowReprice or stop
Reference

Official sources and guidance

Rules, rates and thresholds change. Check the current position at these official sources before acting.

Reference

Key terms in plain English

10 terms
Gross margin
Price less direct costs, divided by price. Prices exclude GST.
Markup
Price less direct costs, divided by direct costs.
Direct cost
A cost that exists only because you did a particular job or sold a particular product.
Fully loaded labour cost
Wages plus super, leave, payroll tax, workers compensation and non-productive time, per productive hour.
Contribution
What a job or product contributes towards overheads and profit after its direct costs.
Constraint or bottleneck
The resource that limits how much you can produce or deliver.
GMROI
Gross margin return on inventory: gross margin dollars ÷ average stock at cost.
Realisation
In services, fees billed divided by the value of time recorded at standard rates.
Prime cost
In hospitality, food and beverage cost plus labour, as a share of sales.
ATO small business benchmarks
Industry ratios published by the ATO, based on tax data from small businesses.
Reference

Questions owners also ask

How do I calculate gross margin on a job?

Take the price excluding GST, subtract all direct costs (materials, fully loaded labour, subcontractors and other direct costs such as freight, fees and waste), and divide the result by the price.

What is the difference between margin and markup?

Margin is profit as a share of the price; markup is profit as a share of cost. A 30% markup gives about a 23% margin.

What is a healthy gross margin?

The one that covers your own overheads, owner pay and target profit. Industry ranges are a useful sense check: roughly 15–35% for trades, 30–55% for retail, 40–70% for professional services and 25–45% for manufacturing, depending on what's counted as a direct cost.

How do I cost labour correctly?

Use the fully loaded cost per productive hour: wages plus super, leave, public holidays, payroll tax and workers compensation, divided by the hours actually spent on paid work.

Should I include my own time in job costs?

Yes, at the cost of employing someone to do it. Otherwise jobs look more profitable than they are.

How do I find which products make the most money?

Calculate gross profit per unit of your scarcest resource, such as per labour hour, machine hour, metre of shelf or dish, and rank by it.

What are ATO small business benchmarks?

Industry ratios, such as cost of sales to turnover, published by the ATO from small business tax data. Businesses well outside the range may attract attention, so they're also a compliance check.

How often should I review margins?

Monthly for live jobs and top products, and fully every quarter.

Keep going

Related owner questions

Want a second pair of eyes on this?

If you'd like margin by job, product or customer set up from your own records, CFOSurge's Australian CFO team can work through it with you, using your actual numbers.

Talk to CFOSurge Australia

CFOSurge Australia · General information only. It isn't financial, tax or legal advice for your circumstances. Worked examples use illustrative figures.