CFOSurge Australia/Owner questions/Finance team

How much should an accountant cost? Split the bill into three, and only compare one part.

5 steps to get there, and a 3-minute check to find where you start.

The problem

Owners compare accountants on one number, so fees feel random and bills sometimes jump.

The way out

Split the bill into core, clean-up and advice. Remove the clean-up, fix the scope, and buy advice on purpose.

The way out, step by step

Five steps to a fair, predictable bill

Hover over a step to light it up, click to open it.Tap a step to open it. 0 of 5 explored

★A fair fee you can predict
A bill that feels random

Not sure which step you’re on?

Take the 3-minute check. Your result lights up your step above.

The full guide

Everything behind your answer, in detail

Read only the sections you need. Each one stands on its own.

Prepared by the CFOSurge Australia team

The answer in brief

Every accounting fee has three parts. The core is the compliance work every business needs: returns, year-end accounts, BAS review. It's the only part you can fairly compare between firms. The clean-up is time spent fixing late, unreconciled or mixed records. It's caused by the state of your books, and it's avoidable. The advice is planning and decision support, the only part that can pay for itself. Ask your accountant for last year's time split across the three, cut the clean-up by fixing your records, turn ad hoc work into a fixed scope, and decide how much advice you want on purpose.

On this page
  1. Five questions first
  2. The three parts of a fee
  3. The usual advice
  4. Audit last year's bill
  5. Remove the avoidable part
  6. Compare quotes on the core
  7. How much advice to buy
  8. Six businesses
  9. Bill shock?
  10. Fee mistakes
  11. Official sources
  12. Key terms
  13. Questions owners also ask
Stage 1 · Notice

Answer five questions before you read on

1Your fee went up a third this year. Did the accountant's prices change, or did your records?

Usually the records. A year of late reconciliations, missing receipts or personal costs mixed in shows up as hours, and hourly firms bill every one.

2Two quotes differ by half. What would you need to know to compare them fairly?

What each includes: how many entities, whether BAS and payroll are covered, how many meetings, whether calls are included, and the rate for anything outside scope. Without that, you're comparing two different products.

3How much of last year's fee went on fixing your records?

Most owners have no idea, and most accountants will tell you if asked. For businesses with messy books, it's often a quarter of the bill or more.

4Which part of your accounting fee could make you money?

Only the advice. Compliance keeps you out of trouble; clean-up repairs the past. Advice changes decisions, so it's the only part that can return more than it costs.

5Is the cheapest accountant the cheapest option?

Not if they do only the core, bill every question and never plan. The cheapest total cost is usually a clean set of books, a fixed scope and paid-for advice you actually use.

Stage 2 · Rebuild

Every accounting fee is three bills added together

1 · Core

Compliance every business needs

Tax returns for each entity, year-end accounts, BAS review or lodgement, routine ATO matters. Comparable between firms once the scope matches.

2 · Clean-up

A tax on messy records

Reconciling months of transactions, chasing missing information, separating personal costs, correcting payroll and GST coding. Caused by you, and avoidable.

3 · Advice

The part that can pay

Tax planning before year-end, structure reviews, help before big decisions. Optional, and worth buying only when it changes a decision.

Then there's a fourth element hiding in the other three: ad hoc work, meaning questions, emails and ATO letters billed as they come. It belongs inside a fixed scope where it becomes predictable.

Stage 3 · Question the usual advice

The usual advice, and why it fails

  • "Shop around for the cheapest." Compares totals that include different amounts of clean-up and advice.
  • "Ask for their hourly rate." Tells you nothing without the hours, and the hours depend on your records.
  • "Do more yourself." Lowers the fee only if what you do is accurate. Errors cost more to fix than to avoid.
Stage 4 · Audit

Audit last year's bill

Ask your accountant for a breakdown of last year's time by task. Most practice software records it. Then sort it into the three parts:

Audit last year's accounting billAsk your accountant for a time breakdown

Three readings are common. A large clean-up share means fix the books first; nothing else will lower the fee as much. A large ad hoc share means agree a fixed scope with calls and letters included. A zero advice share means you're paying only for compliance, which may be fine, but means nobody is planning.

Stage 5 · Reduce

Remove the avoidable part

  1. Reconcile every account monthly, yourself or with a bookkeeper, in cloud software with bank feeds. This alone removes most clean-up.
  2. Separate personal and business with their own accounts and cards. Untangling them is slow, billable work.
  3. Send a complete year-end pack on time: loan statements, asset purchases, stocktake, unpaid invoices and bills, and a note of anything unusual.
  4. Get payroll and super right in software configured for your award, so the accountant isn't correcting it.
  5. Review your entities. Ask what each company or trust is for. One that no longer serves a purpose costs a return every year. Get advice before closing anything.
  6. Batch your questions for scheduled meetings, unless they're urgent.
Stage 6 · Compare

Compare quotes on the core, with this checklist

ItemAsk
Entities and returnsWhich companies, trusts and individual returns are included?
BASPrepared, reviewed or lodged, and how many a year?
Payroll and superIncluded, reviewed or separate?
BookkeepingIncluded, reviewed or separate? What standard do they expect from you?
MeetingsHow many a year, and is there a pre-30 June planning meeting?
Questions and ATO lettersIncluded, capped, or billed?
Out-of-scope workRate, and how it's approved before it's done
TimingWhen will each return be lodged?
SoftwareIs a subscription included?
Fee modelFixed annual, monthly, or hourly with an estimate?
Fee modelSuitsWatch for
Fixed annual feeStable compliance needsClear scope; what triggers extra charges
Monthly fixed feeCompliance plus regular adviceWhat's included each month; exit terms
Hourly with estimateOne-off or unpredictable workAsk for updates before the estimate is exceeded
Value pricingMajor advice or transactionsAgree the outcome clearly
Stage 7 · Decide

How much advice to buy

Advice is worth buying when it's tied to a decision with real money attached: a structure change, an asset purchase, a hire, a loan, owner pay, a sale. A useful rule: if you can't name the decision, don't buy the meeting yet.

Ask for advice to be scoped like compliance: a pre-30 June planning meeting with a tax estimate, a structure review every couple of years, and a set number of decision calls. Then check at year-end what changed because of it.

Stage 8 · Compare

What drove the fee in six businesses

Fees are shown as shares of the bill rather than dollar amounts, because rates vary widely by firm and location.

These are composite businesses with illustrative figures, built to show how the method works. They are not CFOSurge client results.

Hover over a business for a preview (tap on a phone), then click to open the full case.

Stage 9 · Act

Got bill shock? Do this

  1. Ask for a breakdown by task and sort it into the three parts.
  2. Compare it with your engagement letter. Was the extra work in scope, and was it approved?
  3. Ask what caused the extra time. Usually records, a new issue, or ATO correspondence.
  4. Agree a fixed scope and fee for next year, with the standard of records they expect from you.
  5. Fix the cause before the next year-end, usually monthly bookkeeping.
Stage 10 · Avoid

Six fee mistakes

6 mistakes
  • No engagement letter.
  • Comparing totals instead of the core.
  • Annual bookkeeping clean-ups at accountant rates.
  • Keeping unused entities.
  • Hourly billing with no estimate.
  • Buying no advice, then making big decisions alone.
Reference

Official sources and guidance

Rules, rates and thresholds change. Check the current position at these official sources before acting.

Reference

Key terms in plain English

7 terms
Core compliance
The tax returns, accounts and lodgements every business needs.
Clean-up
Time spent fixing or completing records before compliance work can start.
Ad hoc work
Questions, emails and correspondence handled as they arise.
Engagement letter
A written agreement of scope, responsibilities and fees.
Fixed fee
An agreed price for a defined scope.
Out-of-scope work
Work not covered by the agreed scope, usually charged separately.
Entity
A separate legal or tax structure, such as a company, trust or partnership.
Reference

Questions owners also ask

How much should an accountant cost a small business?

It depends on the number of entities, the state of your records, payroll and GST complexity, special issues and how much advice you want. Compare quotes on the core compliance work with a matching scope, and treat clean-up and advice separately.

Why are my accounting fees so high?

Often because a large share is clean-up: reconciling, completing and correcting records. Ask for a time breakdown. Monthly bookkeeping usually removes most of it.

Should I pay a fixed fee or hourly?

A fixed fee suits recurring compliance work; hourly with an estimate suits one-off work. A monthly fixed fee can include a set amount of advice.

How do I compare accountant quotes?

Use the same scope for every quote: entities, BAS, payroll, meetings, questions, ATO letters, out-of-scope rate and timing.

How can I reduce my accounting fees?

Reconcile monthly, keep personal and business separate, send a complete year-end pack on time, get payroll right in software, remove unneeded entities, and agree a fixed scope.

Is accounting advice worth paying for?

When it's tied to a decision with real money attached. If you can't name the decision, wait.

What should be in an engagement letter?

Scope, entities, deliverables, timing, meetings, what's excluded, the out-of-scope rate and fees.

Keep going

Related owner questions

Want a second pair of eyes on this?

If you'd like a second opinion on what you're paying for, and what you actually need, CFOSurge's Australian CFO team can work through it with you, using your actual numbers.

Talk to CFOSurge Australia

CFOSurge Australia · General information only. It isn't financial, tax or legal advice for your circumstances. Worked examples use illustrative figures.