CFOSurge Australia/Owner questions/Finance team

How do I find an accountant who plans ahead? Judge them by the decisions they changed.

5 steps to get there, and a 3-minute check to find where you start.

The problem

Many owners only hear from their accountant after the year ends, when the tax bill can no longer change.

The way out

Judge your accountant by the decisions they changed, do your half of the bargain, and ask the questions that reveal a planner.

The way out, step by step

Five steps to an accountant who plans ahead

Hover over a step to light it up, click to open it.Tap a step to open it. 0 of 5 explored

★Advice before every big decision
Hearing about tax after it's fixed

Not sure which step you’re on?

Take the 3-minute check. Your result lights up your step above.

The full guide

Everything behind your answer, in detail

Read only the sections you need. Each one stands on its own.

Prepared by the CFOSurge Australia team

The answer in brief

The clearest test of a proactive accountant is the decisions they changed. List your five biggest financial decisions of the last year: equipment, hires, owner pay, structure, a loan, a sale. Was your accountant involved before each one? A proactive accountant gives you a tax estimate during the year, meets you before 30 June, raises issues you didn't ask about, reviews your structure as you grow, and is part of big decisions before they're made. Test for it with specific questions, check registration on the Tax Practitioners Board register, agree the planning scope in the engagement letter, and keep your books current, because no one can plan from records that arrive months late.

On this page
  1. Six questions first
  2. The decision test
  3. The usual advice
  4. Test your accountant
  5. Questions to ask
  6. A proactive year
  7. Your half of the bargain
  8. Six businesses
  9. How to switch accountants
  10. Mistakes
  11. Official sources
  12. Key terms
  13. Questions owners also ask
Stage 1 · Notice

Answer six questions before you read on

1What were your five biggest financial decisions last year?

Write them down: a vehicle, a hire, owner pay, a loan, a new contract, a structure change. Now ask: was your accountant involved before any of them? That's the test this page is built on.

2When did your accountant last contact you without being asked?

A proactive accountant starts conversations: a mid-year estimate, a pre-30 June meeting, a note about a rule change that affects you.

3When did you first learn last year's tax bill?

If it was after the return was prepared, the bill was fixed before anyone looked at it. An estimate during the year gives you time to plan and to save.

4Has anyone checked whether your structure still fits?

The structure that suited a start-up often doesn't suit a business with staff, assets and profit. Reviewing it is part of proactive advice.

5Is aggressive tax minimisation the same as good planning?

No. Good planning is legal, documented and fits your cash flow. Buying equipment you don't need in June for a deduction is poor planning: it saves the tax rate and spends the whole amount.

6Could your accountant plan ahead with the records you give them?

If your books are months behind, no. Proactive advice is a two-way arrangement.

Stage 2 · Rebuild

The decision test

Most owners judge their accountant by whether returns go in on time and whether the bill seems fair. Those are compliance measures. They say nothing about whether the accountant made you better off.

The measure that matters is involvement before decisions. Every year contains a handful of decisions where tax, cash and structure meet: buying assets, hiring, owner pay, borrowing, new entities, selling. An accountant who is consulted before those decisions can change the outcome. One who hears about them at year-end can only report it.

Proactive
=
Estimates before deadlinestax known during the year
+
Involvement before decisionsconsulted, not informed
+
Issues raised unpromptedthey call you

Keep a simple decision log: date, decision, amount, and whether your accountant was involved before. After a year, it tells you more than any review.

Stage 3 · Question the usual advice

The usual advice, and what it misses

  • "Get a recommendation." Ask the person what their accountant did for them during the year, not just whether they're happy.
  • "Choose an industry specialist." Helpful, but specialists can be reactive too.
  • "Compare fees." Proactive work costs more because there's more of it. Compare the scope.
Stage 4 · Test

Test your current accountant, and yourself

How proactive is your accountant, and are you?Tick what happened last year
Stage 5 · Interview

Questions that reveal a planner

AskA planner saysA lodger says
What will you do for me in May and June?"We'll meet with a profit and tax estimate and go through options""We'll do your return after year-end"
How will I know my tax bill before it's due?"A mid-year estimate from your management accounts""When we prepare the return"
Tell me about a structure change you recommended recently.A specific example and the reason"Structures don't really change"
I'm thinking of buying a A$60,000 vehicle. What should I ask you first?Questions about cash, finance, use, timing and depreciation"Send us the invoice"
What do you need from me, and when?A timetable and a records standardVague
How are planning and advice charged?Included in a defined scope, or quoted in advanceHourly, no estimate

Then check registration on the Tax Practitioners Board's public register, and whether they belong to a professional body such as CPA Australia, CA ANZ or the IPA.

Stage 6 · Understand

What a proactive year looks like

WhenWhat happens
Start of the yearReview last year; set this year's tax estimate and how much to set aside
Each quarterBAS reviewed; estimate updated from management accounts
MayPlanning meeting: profit estimate, options, decisions with their cash effect
Before 30 JuneAgreed actions done: asset timing, super contributions, trust resolutions, write-offs
After year-endReturns and accounts, with a short debrief on what changed
Any timeA call before any decision in your log

Good planning usually covers the timing of income and expenses, asset purchases and depreciation, owner super contributions within the caps, the mix of owner pay, trust distribution resolutions, bad debts and obsolete stock, and structure. Rules and concessions change, so a proactive accountant checks the current position every year.

Stage 7 · Your side

Your half of the bargain

  1. Keep books reconciled monthly. Planning needs current numbers.
  2. Send management accounts each quarter, or give the accountant access to your software.
  3. Call before decisions, not after. Use your decision log as the trigger.
  4. Book the May meeting in January.
  5. Agree the planning scope in the engagement letter, so neither side hesitates to call.
Stage 8 · Compare

Decisions a proactive accountant changed in six businesses

These are composite businesses with illustrative figures, built to show how the method works. They are not CFOSurge client results.

Hover over a business for a preview (tap on a phone), then click to open the full case.

Stage 9 · Act

How to switch accountants

  1. Engage the new accountant with a signed engagement letter that includes planning.
  2. The new accountant contacts the old one for a professional handover of records and outstanding matters.
  3. The new tax agent adds you to their ATO client list.
  4. Give access to your accounting software and prior returns.
  5. Settle outstanding fees with the previous accountant.
  6. Switch early in the year, not in the weeks before lodgement deadlines.
Stage 10 · Avoid

Six mistakes

6 mistakes
  • Judging an accountant only on lodgement.
  • No planning scope in the engagement letter.
  • Books not ready for the May meeting.
  • Calling after the decision.
  • Unregistered advisers charging for tax advice.
  • Schemes that promise to eliminate tax.
Reference

Official sources and guidance

Rules, rates and thresholds change. Check the current position at these official sources before acting.

Reference

Key terms in plain English

6 terms
Registered tax agent
A person or firm registered with the Tax Practitioners Board to provide tax services for a fee.
Tax Practitioners Board
The regulator of tax and BAS agents, with a public register.
Decision log
A simple record of significant financial decisions, and whether your accountant was consulted first.
Engagement letter
A written agreement setting out scope, responsibilities and fees.
Tax planning
Legitimately arranging affairs before year-end to manage tax within the law.
PAYG instalments
Prepayments of expected income tax during the year.
Reference

Questions owners also ask

What does a proactive accountant do?

Estimates your tax during the year, meets you before 30 June, raises issues and opportunities you didn't ask about, reviews your structure as you grow, and is consulted before big financial decisions.

How can I tell if my accountant is proactive?

List your biggest financial decisions of the last year and ask whether your accountant was involved before each one. Also: did you get a tax estimate before year-end, and did you meet before 30 June?

How do I find a proactive accountant?

Ask what they'll do for you in May and June, how they estimate tax mid-year, and for a recent example of structure advice. Check registration and agree a planning scope in writing.

How do I check an accountant is registered?

Search the Tax Practitioners Board's public register.

Is proactive tax planning legal?

Yes, when it uses the law as intended and is properly documented. Be wary of anyone promising to eliminate tax.

How do I change accountants?

Engage the new accountant, who arranges a handover with the old one and updates the ATO client list. Switch early in the year.

Why does proactive advice cost more?

Because there's more work: estimates, meetings and decision support during the year. It's worth it when it changes decisions with real money attached.

Keep going

Related owner questions

Want a second pair of eyes on this?

If you'd like forward-looking numbers to take into planning with your accountant, CFOSurge's Australian CFO team can work through it with you, using your actual numbers.

Talk to CFOSurge Australia

CFOSurge Australia · General information only. It isn't financial, tax or legal advice for your circumstances. Worked examples use illustrative figures.