Answer six questions before you read on
1Look at your business account balance right now. How much of it belongs to the ATO?
If you can't say within a minute, the balance is misleading you. GST collected, tax withheld from wages and super owed are all in there.
2When was the last time a BAS or tax bill felt like a surprise?
A tax bill should never be a surprise: you knew it was coming from the first sale. It only feels like one when the money was spent in between.
3Do you decide what to pay yourself, or does the bank balance decide for you?
If you take more in good weeks and less in bad ones, the balance is deciding. A separate owner pay account makes it a decision.
4If you could see only one number each morning, which would it be?
Most owners say "what I can spend". A single account can't show that. An operating account, with everything owed already moved out, can.
5Where does profit go if you never move it anywhere?
Into running costs. Money left in the operating account gets used. Profit you want to keep has to be moved out on purpose.
6Would more accounts make this better?
Only up to a point. Four or five accounts with clear jobs work. Ten becomes admin nobody keeps up with.
Why one account misleads you
Behaviour follows what you see. When all the money sits together, the balance looks like spending money, so it gets spent: on stock, equipment, drawings, a hire. Then the BAS arrives and the shortfall appears.
Separate accounts don't change how much money you have. They change what you see, and so what you do. It's the same principle as the "free cash" calculation, built into your banking so it happens automatically.
The usual advice, and where it falls short
- "Put a percentage aside for tax." Right idea, but which percentage, and when?
- "Follow Profit First." A popular method that allocates income to profit, owner pay, tax and operating accounts. Useful, but its suggested percentages may not fit your margin.
- "Your accountant will tell you what you owe." Usually after the period, which is too late to have set it aside.
Give every dollar one job
Every dollar that arrives in the business has one of five jobs. Give each job its own account:
| Account | Its job | Money in | Money out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Income | Receive everything | All customer payments | Transfers to the others, on a set day |
| GST and tax | Hold what's owed to the ATO | GST share, PAYG withheld, income tax allowance | BAS, PAYG instalments, tax bills only |
| Owner pay | Fund a steady owner wage | A fixed share | Your regular pay to yourself |
| Profit or reserve | Keep what the business earns | A fixed share | Reserve top-ups, quarterly distributions, planned investment |
| Operating | Run the business | What's left | Wages, suppliers, rent, everything else |
Super can sit in the tax account or its own; either way, it's never spending money. If you hold customer deposits for work not yet delivered, consider keeping them separate too.
Set the percentages from your own numbers
The GST share is arithmetic: if your sales carry GST at the standard rate, one-eleventh of what you receive is GST. The other percentages come from your accounts:
- Income tax allowance: last year's income tax ÷ last year's sales excluding GST, adjusted for this year's expected profit. Your tax agent can estimate it.
- Owner pay: what you need to take each month ÷ average monthly sales, capped at what the business can safely carry (see how much can I pay myself).
- Profit or reserve: start small, a few percent, and raise it each quarter as the operating account copes.
If the operating amount can't cover your running costs, the percentages aren't the problem. Your margin is, and that's worth knowing.
Set it up and run it
- Open the accounts with your current bank.
Most business banks let you open extra accounts online at little or no cost. Name each one by its job.
- Point all customer payments to the income account.
- Choose your transfer days.
Weekly or twice a month suits most businesses. Daily suits hospitality and retail with high card takings.
- Move the percentages on each transfer day, from the income account to each of the others. Automate fixed transfers where your bank allows.
- Pay every bill from the right account. BAS and tax from the tax account; wages and suppliers from operating; your pay from owner pay.
- Reconcile once a quarter.
After each BAS, check the tax account had enough. If it was short, raise the percentage; if there's a lot left, check with your tax agent before lowering it.
- Tell your bookkeeper. Transfers between your own accounts aren't income or expenses, and need to be coded as transfers.
The same idea in six businesses
The accounts are the same. The percentages, timing and traps differ.
These are composite businesses with illustrative figures, built to show how the method works. They are not CFOSurge client results.
Sole trader painter, A$180K revenue
Weekly split on A$4,400 received, including GST (illustrative example)
| GST (one-eleventh) | A$400 |
| Income tax and PAYG instalment allowance | A$480 |
| Owner pay | A$1,600 |
| Profit and reserve | A$200 |
| Operating: paint, van, insurance, phone | A$1,720 |
| Spendable each week | A$1,720 |
The diagnosis
The painter had been treating the whole balance as income. A quarter of every payment was owed to the ATO or needed for running costs, so each quarter's BAS came out of personal savings.
The full solution, in order
- Open four accounts: income, tax, owner pay, operating.
- Move the split every Friday, or each time a payment lands.
- Pay yourself a fixed weekly amount from the owner pay account.
- Pay the BAS and PAYG instalments only from the tax account.
- Check after each BAS that the tax account had enough.
- Name each account by its job in your banking app so it's obvious at a glance.
- Ask your tax agent to confirm the income tax percentage once a year.
Don't do this
- Skipping the transfer in a slow week.
- Using the tax account for materials.
- Paying yourself straight from the income account.
Numbers to watch every month
- Tax account balance against the next BAS
- Operating account low point
- Owner pay consistency
Builder, A$2.4M revenue
Split of a A$110,000 progress claim, including GST (illustrative example)
| GST (one-eleventh) | A$10,000 |
| Income tax allowance | A$3,000 |
| Defects and retentions provision | A$2,000 |
| Owner pay | A$4,000 |
| Operating: subcontractors, materials, wages | A$91,000 |
| Available to run the job | A$91,000 |
The diagnosis
Lump-sum claims create false confidence. The builder now moves the GST and tax share the day each claim lands, and keeps a small provision for defects on completed jobs.
The full solution, in order
- Move the split the day each claim is paid.
- Add a defects provision account for warranty work on completed jobs.
- Pay subcontractors from operating only.
- Keep PAYG withheld and super in the tax account until paid.
- Hold retention releases in the profit account until defects periods end.
- Review the split each quarter against job margins.
Don't do this
- Paying a deposit on new equipment because a claim just landed.
- Using GST from one job to fund another.
- Mixing retention releases into operating.
Numbers to watch every month
- Tax account against BAS due
- Defects provision
- Operating low point between claims
Online store, A$1.5M revenue
Daily split on A$4,950 of payouts, including GST (illustrative example)
| GST (one-eleventh) | A$450 |
| Income tax allowance | A$140 |
| Profit and reserve | A$225 |
| Stock fund for reorders | A$1,800 |
| Operating | A$2,335 |
| Operating each day | A$2,335 |
The diagnosis
For a stock business, a separate stock fund matters as much as the tax account. Without it, reorders compete with marketing and wages for the same cash.
The full solution, in order
- Sweep GST and tax daily with an automatic transfer.
- Add a stock fund sized to the cost of goods sold each day.
- Plan peak-season orders from the stock fund and the forecast.
- Review percentages each quarter as margin changes.
- Size the stock fund from cost of goods sold, and review it before each season.
- Keep marketing spend in operating, capped by a monthly budget.
Don't do this
- Funding stock from the tax account.
- Letting marketing spend from the stock fund.
- Counting marketplace balances before payout.
Numbers to watch every month
- Tax account against BAS due
- Stock fund against planned orders
- Operating low point
Two-director consultancy, A$1.6M revenue
Fortnightly split on A$66,000 received, including GST (illustrative example)
| GST (one-eleventh) | A$6,000 |
| Company income tax allowance | A$4,800 |
| Directors' pay | A$12,000 |
| Profit and reserve | A$3,000 |
| Operating: salaries, rent, software | A$40,200 |
| Operating each fortnight | A$40,200 |
The diagnosis
Directors' pay followed the bank balance, so it was highest just before the tax bill. A fixed directors' pay account, with dividends paid only from the profit account each quarter, fixed both.
The full solution, in order
- Set a fixed directors' pay amount from the owner pay account.
- Pay dividends quarterly from the profit account, after tax is provided for.
- Keep PAYG withheld and super in a payroll account until paid.
- Ask your tax agent for an income tax percentage based on expected profit.
- Hold PAYG withheld and super in a payroll account funded before each pay run.
- Review the profit percentage each quarter and raise it when the operating account copes.
Don't do this
- Directors drawing from the operating account.
- Paying dividends from the tax account.
- Borrowing to pay tax that was already collected.
Numbers to watch every month
- Tax account against estimated liability
- Profit account balance
- Directors' pay against plan
Café, A$900K revenue
Daily split on A$2,750 of takings, including GST (illustrative example)
| GST (one-eleventh) | A$250 |
| PAYG withheld and super for the day's wages | A$180 |
| Income tax allowance | A$60 |
| Equipment and quiet-season fund | A$110 |
| Operating | A$2,150 |
| Operating each day | A$2,150 |
The diagnosis
Hospitality holds a lot of other people's money: GST on every sale and tax withheld from a large wage bill. A daily automatic sweep is the single most effective cash habit a café can adopt.
The full solution, in order
- Automate a daily sweep of GST, PAYG withheld and super.
- Add an equipment and quiet-season fund.
- Pay the BAS only from the tax account.
- Review after each BAS and adjust the percentages.
- Set up the sweep as a scheduled transfer so it happens without anyone remembering.
- Count the till float separately from all accounts.
Don't do this
- Weekly or monthly sweeps that leave too long to spend it.
- Using the tax account for stock.
- Counting the quiet-season fund as operating cash.
Numbers to watch every month
- Tax account against BAS due
- Quiet-season fund
- Wages as a share of takings
Food manufacturer, A$6.25M revenue
Weekly allocation on A$132,000 received, including GST (illustrative example)
| GST (one-eleventh) | A$12,000 |
| Payroll account: net wages, PAYG withheld, super | A$42,000 |
| Income tax allowance | A$5,000 |
| Equipment maintenance fund | A$3,000 |
| Operating: materials, overheads | A$70,000 |
| Operating each week | A$70,000 |
The diagnosis
At this size, a dedicated payroll account works better than a general tax account. It's funded before each pay run, so wages, PAYG withheld and super are always covered.
The full solution, in order
- Fund the payroll account before every pay run, including PAYG withheld and super.
- Keep GST in its own account for the BAS.
- Hold an equipment maintenance fund for planned overhauls.
- Use the 13-week forecast to set the transfers.
- Forecast each account's balance in the 13-week forecast.
- Review the maintenance fund against the equipment plan each year.
Don't do this
- Running payroll from operating.
- Letting materials spending draw on GST.
- Skipping maintenance funding.
Numbers to watch every month
- Payroll account before each run
- GST account against BAS
- Maintenance fund
Hover over a business for a preview (tap on a phone), then click to open the full case.
Already behind on tax? Start here
- Open the tax account today and start moving the GST share of every receipt, even if the past amount can't be covered yet.
- Work out what's owed now. Your last BAS position and any income tax due.
- If you can't pay it on time, contact the ATO before the due date and propose a payment plan you can keep alongside the new transfers.
- Keep super separate and paid on time. It's your employees' money, and directors can become personally liable for some unpaid amounts.
- Cut owner pay temporarily rather than skipping the tax transfers.
Stage 9 · AvoidSix mistakes with separate accounts
6 mistakes
- Borrowing from the tax account "just until Friday".
- Generic percentages that don't match your margin.
- Too many accounts. The system collapses when it takes too long.
- Skipping transfers in tight weeks. That's exactly when they matter.
- Coding transfers as expenses, which distorts the books.
- Never reviewing the percentages as the business changes.
Stage 10 · DecideWhich setup for which business
Summary table
| Business | Accounts | Transfer timing |
|---|---|---|
| Sole trader | Income, tax, owner pay, operating | Weekly, or every time a payment lands |
| Card-heavy (hospitality, retail) | Income, tax, profit, operating | Daily or every few days |
| Project-based (construction) | Add a retentions or defects provision | Each time a claim is paid |
| Services firm | Income, tax, owner pay, profit, operating | Weekly or fortnightly |
| Larger employer | Add a separate payroll and super account | Before each pay run |
Official sources and guidance
Rules, rates and thresholds change. Check the current position at these official sources before acting.
- business.gov.au: Set up your business bank accountSeparating business and personal finances.
- ATO: GSTRegistration, charging GST, credits and reporting.
- ATO: Business activity statementsWhat goes on a BAS and when it's due.
- ATO: PAYG withholdingWithholding tax from wages and paying it to the ATO.
- ATO: PAYG instalmentsHow income tax instalments work and how to vary them.
- ATO: Super for employersCurrent Super Guarantee rate, who you pay super for, and due dates.
ReferenceKey terms in plain English
7 terms
- GST
- Goods and services tax collected on taxable sales. You hold it for the ATO until you pay it with your BAS.
- BAS
- Business activity statement, used to report and pay GST, PAYG withheld and PAYG instalments.
- PAYG withheld
- Tax you deduct from employees' wages and pay to the ATO.
- PAYG instalments
- Regular prepayments of your expected income tax.
- Profit First
- A cash management method that allocates income to profit, owner pay, tax and operating accounts by percentage.
- Operating account
- The account that pays day-to-day running costs.
- Transfer (in bookkeeping)
- Moving money between your own accounts. It isn't income or an expense.
Questions owners also ask
Should I have a separate bank account for GST?
Yes. Moving the GST share of every receipt into its own account means you never spend it, and the BAS is already funded when it's due.
How much should I set aside for GST?
If all your sales carry GST at the standard rate, one-eleventh of everything you receive. Your GST credits on purchases reduce what you pay, but setting aside the full amount is the safe default.
How much should I set aside for income tax?
Base it on last year's income tax as a share of sales, adjusted for this year's expected profit. Your tax agent can estimate the right percentage.
How many business bank accounts do I need?
Usually four or five: income, GST and tax, owner pay, profit or reserve, and operating. Larger employers may add a payroll account.
Is Profit First a good system?
The principle of allocating money by job before spending it works well. Set the percentages from your own margin and tax position rather than using generic ones.
How often should I transfer money between accounts?
Weekly or fortnightly for most businesses; daily for card-heavy businesses like cafés and retailers.
Do transfers between my accounts affect tax?
No. Moving money between your own accounts isn't income or an expense. Make sure your bookkeeper codes them as transfers.
What if the operating account runs short?
Don't raid the tax account. A persistent shortfall means margin or owner pay needs to change. Lower the profit percentage temporarily and look at pricing and costs.
Related owner questions
Want a second pair of eyes on this?
If you'd like the percentages set from your own accounts and tax position, CFOSurge's Australian CFO team can work through it with you, using your actual numbers.