CFOSurge Australia/Owner questions/Systems

How do I choose accounting software? Choose where each fact gets entered, once.

5 steps to get there, and a 3-minute check to find where you start.

The problem

When every sale and bill is typed in more than once, numbers are late, wrong and expensive to produce.

The way out

Map where each fact starts, connect it once, check the Australian essentials, then test the choice with a real week.

The way out, step by step

Five steps to data that flows once

Hover over a step to light it up, click to open it.Tap a step to open it. 0 of 5 explored

★Enter once, report anywhere
Typing the same thing three times

Not sure which step you’re on?

Take the 3-minute check. Your result lights up your step above.

The full guide

Everything behind your answer, in detail

Read only the sections you need. Each one stands on its own.

Prepared by the CFOSurge Australia team

The answer in brief

Every Australian business needs bank feeds, GST and BAS reporting, Single Touch Payroll if it has employees, invoicing with online payment, and access for its bookkeeper and accountant. Beyond that, the right software is the one that lets each fact be entered once, at its source: a sale at the till, website or job app; a bill from the supplier's email; hours from a timesheet; stock from the warehouse. Map where each kind of transaction starts, count how much is currently retyped, shortlist two or three packages that connect to those sources, test each with a real week of transactions, check which your accountant supports, and price the full setup including add-ons. Switch at a period end.

On this page
  1. Five questions first
  2. Enter it once, at the source
  3. The usual advice
  4. Non-negotiables
  5. Map your sources
  6. Test with a real week
  7. Six businesses
  8. Switching
  9. Mistakes
  10. Official sources
  11. Key terms
  12. Questions owners also ask
Stage 1 · Notice

Answer five questions before you read on

1How many times is a single sale typed in before it reaches your accounts?

Often two or three: once in a quote or job app, once on an invoice, once in the accounts. Every retype costs time and adds errors.

2Who in your business knows each fact first?

The person at the till knows the sale, the tradesperson knows the hours, the supplier knows the bill. Good systems capture the fact from them, not from someone typing it later.

3Which package does your accountant work in every day?

Choosing one they know well usually means faster, cheaper work and better advice.

4What will it really cost each month?

The headline plan is only part of it. Payroll per employee, add-ons for stock or jobs, and extra users can multiply it.

5If you wanted to leave in three years, could you take your data?

Check export options before you start, not when you want to go.

Stage 2 · Rebuild

Enter each fact once, at its source

Accounting software is where information ends up, not where it begins. Every transaction starts somewhere else: a till, a website, a quote, a timesheet, a supplier's invoice, a bank. The question that decides whether your setup works is simple: does each fact get entered once, where it starts, by the person closest to it, and then flow through without being retyped?

FactWhere it startsHow it should arrive in the accounts
A saleTill, website, marketplace, job app, quoteIntegration posting gross sales, fees, refunds and GST
A supplier billThe supplier's emailBill capture: forwarded or scanned, read automatically, approved once
A paymentThe bankBank feed, matched by rules
Hours workedTimesheet or job appPayroll and job costing from the same entry
Stock movementReceiving and dispatchInventory system linked to sales and purchases

When a fact is typed twice, three things happen: someone spends time on it, a share of entries are wrong, and the numbers are late. All three cost money, and the last one costs the most, because late numbers mean late decisions.

What retyping data costs youExample figures · replace with yours
Stage 3 · Question the usual advice

The usual advice, and why it's incomplete

  • "Pick the most popular one." A fine shortlist, not a decision.
  • "Compare feature lists." Every list looks complete. Fit shows only when you test with your own transactions.
  • "Choose the cheapest plan." Missing connections end up as retyping, which costs more than the plan saved.
Stage 4 · Requirements

The non-negotiables for an Australian business

  • Bank and card feeds from your banks.
  • GST coding and BAS reporting, with lodgement or an easy handover to your agent.
  • Single Touch Payroll if you have employees, with award-capable payroll if your staff are award-covered.
  • Super payments processed through payroll.
  • Invoicing with online payment options.
  • Accountant and bookkeeper access at no extra cost.
  • Data export, user permissions and two-factor authentication.
  • Records kept for as long as the law requires, including after you stop subscribing.
Stage 5 · Map

Map your sources, then shortlist

  1. List every way money comes in and goes out: each sales channel, supplier type, payroll, loans.
  2. For each, write where the fact starts and who knows it first.
  3. Mark where it's retyped today. These are the connections you need.
  4. List the reports you need without spreadsheets: profit by job, product, site or customer; aged debtors; cash forecast.
  5. Shortlist two or three packages whose integrations cover your sources and whose reports cover your list. Widely used options in Australia, such as Xero, MYOB and QuickBooks, all cover the basics; they differ in add-ons, pricing tiers and integrations.
Stage 6 · Test

Test with a real week

  1. Start a free trial of each shortlisted package.
  2. Connect the bank and your main sales source.
  3. Put a real week through it: sales, a few supplier bills, a pay run if possible.
  4. Count the retyping that's still left.
  5. Run the reports on your list.
  6. Ask your accountant and bookkeeper which they support well.
  7. Price the full setup: plan, payroll per employee, add-ons, users.
Stage 7 · Compare

Where the facts start in six businesses

These are composite businesses with illustrative figures, built to show how the method works. They are not CFOSurge client results.

Hover over a business for a preview (tap on a phone), then click to open the full case.

Stage 8 · Act

How to switch accounting software

  1. Switch at a period end: ideally the financial year end, or at least a quarter end after the BAS.
  2. Reconcile everything in the old system first.
  3. Bring across opening balances, open invoices and bills, and payroll year-to-date figures.
  4. Set up the chart of accounts with your accountant.
  5. Reconnect integrations and test each with real transactions.
  6. Run payroll in parallel for one cycle if you can.
  7. Keep exports or read-only access to the old system to meet record-keeping obligations.
Stage 9 · Avoid

Six software mistakes

6 mistakes
  • Choosing before mapping your sources.
  • Ignoring add-on and per-employee costs.
  • Switching mid-quarter.
  • Not involving your accountant.
  • Manual workarounds where an integration exists.
  • No plan for keeping old records.
Reference

Official sources and guidance

Rules, rates and thresholds change. Check the current position at these official sources before acting.

Reference

Key terms in plain English

7 terms
Bank feed
An automatic import of bank transactions into accounting software.
Single Touch Payroll (STP)
Reporting payroll information to the ATO each time you pay employees.
Integration
A connection that passes data automatically between apps.
Bill capture
Reading supplier bills from email or scans into the accounts automatically.
Chart of accounts
The list of categories used to record transactions.
Tracking category
A tag for reporting by job, site, department or project.
Bill of materials
The list of components and quantities used to make a product.
Reference

Questions owners also ask

What is the best accounting software for a small business in Australia?

The one that covers the Australian essentials (bank feeds, GST and BAS, Single Touch Payroll) and connects to where your transactions start, so nothing is typed twice. Shortlist two or three, test with a real week and ask your accountant.

Xero, MYOB or QuickBooks?

All cover the basics for Australian businesses. Compare their integrations with your sales and job systems, how they handle your inventory or payroll needs, and the total cost with add-ons.

Do I need Single Touch Payroll?

Yes, if you have employees. Your payroll software must report through STP.

How do I work out if an integration is worth it?

Count the entries retyped each month, multiply by the time and the hourly cost, and add the cost of fixing errors. If the integration costs less than that, it pays for itself.

How do I switch accounting software?

Switch at a period end, reconcile the old system, bring across opening balances and open items, reconnect integrations and keep the old records.

Can my accountant help choose?

Yes, and they should. Software they support well usually means faster, cheaper work.

Keep going

Related owner questions

Want a second pair of eyes on this?

If you'd like help mapping your sources and choosing systems that produce the reports you need, CFOSurge's Australian CFO team can work through it with you, using your actual numbers.

Talk to CFOSurge Australia

CFOSurge Australia · General information only. It isn't financial, tax or legal advice for your circumstances. Worked examples use illustrative figures.