CFOSurge Australia/Owner questions/Funding

Overdraft, invoice finance or a business loan? What each one really costs.

6 steps to get there, and a 3-minute check to find where you start.

The problem

Lenders price finance in ways that are hard to compare, and the cheapest-looking offer is often the most expensive.

The way out

Decide what the money is for, how long you need it and what repays it. Then compare every offer on one number: effective yearly cost.

The way out, step by step

Six signposts to the right finance

Hover over a step to light it up, click to open it.Tap a step to open it. 0 of 6 explored

★The right finance, fairly priced
Lost between offers

Not sure which step you’re on?

Take the 3-minute check. Your result lights up your step above.

The full guide

Everything behind your answer, in detail

Read only the sections you need. Each one stands on its own.

Prepared by the CFOSurge Australia team

The answer in brief

Compare finance on its effective yearly cost: all interest and fees over the period you actually need the money, divided by the average amount you have the use of. Fixed fees on loans repaid weekly or daily look cheap but often cost two or three times the headline percentage. Then match the finance to its purpose: timing gaps suit a facility you draw and repay (overdraft, line of credit, invoice finance); equipment suits finance over the asset's working life; and no finance fixes a business that isn't making enough margin. Always check that the cash to repay it will exist.

On this page
  1. Six questions first
  2. Why quotes don't compare
  3. The usual advice
  4. Match finance to purpose
  5. Compare two quotes
  6. The options in plain English
  7. Six businesses
  8. Before you sign
  9. Finance mistakes
  10. Need to finance match
  11. Official sources
  12. Key terms
  13. Questions owners also ask
Stage 1 · Notice

Answer six questions before you read on

1A lender offers A$100,000 for six months with a "factor rate" of 1.15. What's the interest rate?

Not 15%. You repay A$115,000 over six months, usually daily or weekly, so on average you only have about half the money for the period. The effective yearly cost is roughly 60%.

2You need cash for three months, and the loan on offer is for 12. What does that cost you?

Interest on money you don't need for nine months, plus early repayment fees if you pay it off. Term matters as much as rate.

3What will you use to repay this finance?

If you can't point to the cash that will repay it, such as a customer payment, the asset's earnings, or a seasonal upswing, the finance is covering a deeper problem rather than solving it.

4Is an overdraft you never draw free?

Not usually. Many facilities charge a line fee or limit fee on the whole limit, drawn or not. It can still be worth it as insurance, but count the cost.

5Why would a lender offer you A$80,000 against invoices but refuse a A$80,000 loan?

Because the invoices are security. Invoice finance lends against your customers' ability to pay, which can be easier to approve than lending against your business's track record.

6Is the cheapest rate always the best finance?

No. The best finance matches the purpose, the term and the way you'll repay it, at a cost the use of the money justifies. A cheap loan for the wrong job is expensive.

Stage 2 · Understand

Why finance quotes are so hard to compare

Interest rate

% a year on the balance

Banks and many lenders. Cost falls as you repay.

Factor rate or flat fee

A fixed amount on the full loan

Many short-term lenders and cash advances. Cost doesn't fall as you repay, so the effective rate is much higher than it looks.

% of invoices

A service fee per invoice or on turnover

Invoice finance. Usually a fee plus interest on what's advanced.

Fees

Establishment, line, monthly, early exit

Often a large share of the true cost, especially on small or short loans.

Stage 3 · Question the usual advice

The usual advice, and what it misses

  • "Compare interest rates." Misses fees and flat-rate pricing.
  • "Go to your bank first." Good starting point, but banks often need property security and take weeks.
  • "Borrow as little as possible." Too small a facility can be more dangerous than paying for headroom.
  • "Avoid debt." The right finance for a timing gap or an earning asset can be cheaper than the alternative: missed payments, lost orders or a drained reserve.
The gap: none of this asks what the money is for. Mismatched finance, such as a long loan for a short gap or an overdraft for equipment, causes more damage than paying a point or two more on the right product.
Stage 4 · Rebuild

Match the finance to the job it's doing

Every finance decision answers three questions. Get them right and the product almost chooses itself:

1 · What is it for?

A timing gap (customers pay later than you pay costs) needs a facility you draw and repay. An earning asset needs finance over its working life. A loss or thin margin isn't a finance problem, and borrowing makes it worse.

2 · For how long?

Match the term to the need. Short gaps need short or revolving finance. Assets need terms that match how long they'll earn.

3 · What repays it?

Name the cash: the customer receipts it bridges, the asset's earnings, the seasonal upswing. If nothing obvious repays it, stop.

Effective cost
=
All interest and feesover the time you need it
÷
Average amount you havefalls as you repay
÷
Yearsmonths ÷ 12
Stage 5 · Compare quotes

Turn two quotes into one comparable number

Compare two finance optionsEnter each lender's quote

Ask every lender for the same four things in writing: the interest rate or fee basis, every fee (establishment, monthly, line, early exit), how and how often you repay, and what security or guarantees they need.

Stage 6 · Choose

The main options, in plain English

OptionHow it worksBest forWatch for
OverdraftA limit on your transaction account; interest on what you useShort timing gapsUsually needs property security; line fees on the whole limit; can be reduced at review
Line of creditA separate revolving facility you draw and repayRecurring gaps, seasonal stockSame as overdraft; minimum drawdowns
Invoice financeAn advance of part of each invoice; the rest, less fees, when the customer paysGrowing businesses with creditworthy business customersService fees plus interest; some versions notify your customers; minimum terms
Trade financeThe lender pays your supplier; you repay when the goods sellImporters and stock purchasesFees per drawing; short terms
Equipment financeChattel mortgage, lease or hire purchase secured on the assetVehicles, plant, equipmentBalloon payments; early payout costs; match term to working life
Secured term loanA fixed amount repaid over years, secured on property or assetsLong-term needs: buying a business, major projectsPersonal guarantees; covenants
Unsecured business loanFast approval, usually short terms and frequent repaymentsShort, urgent, clearly repayable needsFlat fees and factor rates make the true cost high
Merchant cash advanceA lump sum repaid from a share of daily card takingsCard-heavy businesses in a pinchFixed fee regardless of how fast you repay; often the most expensive option
Business credit cardRevolving credit with an interest-free periodSmall, short purchases repaid in fullHigh rates if a balance is carried
Tax payment planPaying an ATO debt in instalmentsA tax bill you can't meet on timeThe general interest charge is set quarterly and can exceed bank rates; check its current rate and whether it's deductible
Stage 7 · Compare cases

Six businesses, six finance decisions

Each case compares real-world style quotes using the effective-cost method. Figures are illustrative; your quotes will differ.

These are composite businesses with illustrative figures, built to show how the method works. They are not CFOSurge client results.

Hover over a business for a preview (tap on a phone), then click to open the full case.

Stage 8 · Act

Before you sign anything

  1. Write down the purpose, term and repayment source in one sentence each.
  2. Get at least two written quotes and convert both with the calculator.
  3. Read the fees schedule, especially early repayment, line fees and default fees.
  4. Check security and guarantees. A personal guarantee or a mortgage over your home puts personal assets at risk.
  5. Check covenants and review terms. Some facilities can be reduced or recalled if results dip.
  6. Run the 13-week forecast with the repayments in. If any week goes negative, the finance doesn't fit.
  7. Consider independent advice on large or secured borrowing.
Stage 9 · Avoid

Seven finance mistakes

7 mistakes
  • Comparing headline rates instead of effective cost.
  • Using an overdraft for equipment. Short-term money for a long-term asset.
  • Taking a 12-month loan for a 3-month gap.
  • Stacking short-term loans to repay each other.
  • Borrowing to cover losses.
  • Signing a personal guarantee without reading it.
  • Sizing a facility with no headroom, then breaching it in the first bad month.
Stage 10 · Decide

Which finance for which need

Summary table
NeedUsually fitsUsually doesn't
Customers pay slower than you pay costsOverdraft, line of credit, invoice financeLong term loan
Seasonal or import stockTrade finance, line of creditMerchant cash advance
Vehicles, plant, fit-outEquipment finance over its working lifeOverdraft, credit card
A one-off urgent gap with clear repaymentShort unsecured loan, if the effective cost is justifiedRolling short-term loans
Ongoing lossesFixing margin firstAny debt
Tax bill you can't meetPayment plan or cheaper finance; compare costsIgnoring it
Reference

Official sources and guidance

Rules, rates and thresholds change. Check the current position at these official sources before acting.

Reference

Key terms in plain English

12 terms
Effective yearly cost
All interest and fees divided by the average amount you have the use of, expressed per year.
Factor rate
A multiplier applied to the amount borrowed to set the total repayable, such as 1.15. Not an interest rate.
Overdraft
A borrowing limit on a transaction account; interest is charged on the amount used.
Line of credit
A revolving facility you can draw, repay and redraw up to a limit.
Line fee
A fee charged on the whole facility limit, whether or not it's used.
Invoice finance
Funding advanced against unpaid customer invoices.
Trade finance
Finance that pays suppliers for stock or imports, repaid when the goods are sold.
Chattel mortgage
Equipment finance where you own the asset and the lender takes security over it.
Balloon payment
A large final payment at the end of a finance term.
Personal guarantee
A promise by a director or owner to repay the business's debt personally if the business can't.
Covenant
A condition in a loan agreement, such as minimum profit or maximum debt levels.
Merchant cash advance
A lump sum repaid from a share of future card takings, priced as a fixed fee.
Reference

Questions owners also ask

What is the cheapest way to borrow for a business?

Usually secured bank finance, such as an overdraft or loan secured on property, followed by equipment finance secured on the asset. Unsecured loans and cash advances are usually the most expensive. The right choice also depends on purpose, term and what security you're prepared to give.

What is a factor rate?

A multiplier that sets the total you repay, such as 1.15 times the amount borrowed. Because the fee is fixed and you usually repay daily or weekly, the effective yearly cost is often several times the factor rate's percentage.

Is invoice finance expensive?

It usually costs more than a secured overdraft but less than unsecured short-term loans. Its advantage is that the limit grows with your sales and it's secured on your invoices rather than property.

Overdraft or line of credit?

Both are revolving facilities for timing gaps. An overdraft sits on your transaction account; a line of credit is usually separate. Compare their fees, especially line fees on the full limit.

Should I use a business loan to pay a tax debt?

Compare the effective cost of the loan with the ATO's general interest charge, which is set quarterly, and check its current tax treatment. Either way, contact the ATO before the due date.

What is a merchant cash advance?

A lump sum repaid as a share of your daily card takings, priced as a fixed fee. It's convenient but usually one of the most expensive forms of business finance.

How do I compare two loan offers?

Add all interest and fees over the time you'll need the money, divide by the average amount you'll have, and divide by the number of years. The calculator on this page does this for two quotes.

Do I need a personal guarantee?

Many small business lenders require one. It makes you personally liable if the business can't repay, so read it carefully and consider independent advice.

Should I finance equipment or pay cash?

If paying cash would drain your reserve or working capital, financing over the asset's working life is usually safer, even though it costs interest.

Keep going

Related owner questions

Want a second pair of eyes on this?

If you're weighing finance offers and want an independent view of which fits, CFOSurge's Australian CFO team can work through it with you, using your actual numbers.

Talk to CFOSurge Australia

CFOSurge Australia · General information only. It isn't financial, tax or legal advice for your circumstances. Worked examples use illustrative figures.